bi-agents/.claude/skills/bmad-testarch-test-review/steps-c/step-03f-aggregate-scores.md

name, description, nextStepFile, outputFile

name	description	nextStepFile	outputFile
step-03f-aggregate-scores	Aggregate quality dimension scores into overall 0-100 score	./step-04-generate-report.md	{test_artifacts}/test-review.md

Step 3F: Aggregate Quality Scores

STEP GOAL

Read outputs from 4 quality subagents, calculate weighted overall score (0-100), and aggregate violations for report generation.

---

MANDATORY EXECUTION RULES

• 📖 Read the entire step file before acting
• ✅ Speak in {communication_language}
• ✅ Read all 4 subagent outputs
• ✅ Calculate weighted overall score
• ✅ Aggregate violations by severity
• ❌ Do NOT re-evaluate quality (use subagent outputs)

---

EXECUTION PROTOCOLS:

• 🎯 Follow the MANDATORY SEQUENCE exactly
• 💾 Record outputs before proceeding
• 📖 Load the next step only when instructed

---

MANDATORY SEQUENCE

1. Read All Subagent Outputs

// Use the SAME timestamp generated in Step 3 (do not regenerate).
const timestamp = subagentContext?.timestamp;
if (!timestamp) {
  throw new Error('Missing timestamp from Step 3 context. Pass Step 3 timestamp into Step 3F.');
}
const dimensions = ['determinism', 'isolation', 'maintainability', 'performance'];
const results = {};

dimensions.forEach((dim) => {
  const outputPath = `/tmp/tea-test-review-${dim}-${timestamp}.json`;
  results[dim] = JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync(outputPath, 'utf8'));
});

Verify all succeeded:

const allSucceeded = dimensions.every((dim) => results[dim].score !== undefined);
if (!allSucceeded) {
  throw new Error('One or more quality subagents failed!');
}

---

2. Calculate Weighted Overall Score

Dimension Weights (based on TEA quality priorities):

const weights = {
  determinism: 0.3, // 30% - Reliability and flake prevention
  isolation: 0.3, // 30% - Parallel safety and independence
  maintainability: 0.25, // 25% - Readability and long-term health
  performance: 0.15, // 15% - Speed and execution efficiency
};

Calculate overall score:

const overallScore = dimensions.reduce((sum, dim) => {
  return sum + results[dim].score * weights[dim];
}, 0);

const roundedScore = Math.round(overallScore);

Determine grade:

const getGrade = (score) => {
  if (score >= 90) return 'A';
  if (score >= 80) return 'B';
  if (score >= 70) return 'C';
  if (score >= 60) return 'D';
  return 'F';
};

const overallGrade = getGrade(roundedScore);

---

3. Aggregate Violations by Severity

Collect all violations from all dimensions:

const allViolations = dimensions.flatMap((dim) =>
  results[dim].violations.map((v) => ({
    ...v,
    dimension: dim,
  })),
);

// Group by severity
const highSeverity = allViolations.filter((v) => v.severity === 'HIGH');
const mediumSeverity = allViolations.filter((v) => v.severity === 'MEDIUM');
const lowSeverity = allViolations.filter((v) => v.severity === 'LOW');

const violationSummary = {
  total: allViolations.length,
  HIGH: highSeverity.length,
  MEDIUM: mediumSeverity.length,
  LOW: lowSeverity.length,
};

---

4. Prioritize Recommendations

Extract recommendations from all dimensions:

const allRecommendations = dimensions.flatMap((dim) =>
  results[dim].recommendations.map((rec) => ({
    dimension: dim,
    recommendation: rec,
    impact: results[dim].score < 70 ? 'HIGH' : 'MEDIUM',
  })),
);

// Sort by impact (HIGH first)
const prioritizedRecommendations = allRecommendations.sort((a, b) => (a.impact === 'HIGH' ? -1 : 1)).slice(0, 10); // Top 10 recommendations

---

5. Create Review Summary Object

Aggregate all results:

const reviewSummary = {
  overall_score: roundedScore,
  overall_grade: overallGrade,
  quality_assessment: getQualityAssessment(roundedScore),

  dimension_scores: {
    determinism: results.determinism.score,
    isolation: results.isolation.score,
    maintainability: results.maintainability.score,
    performance: results.performance.score,
  },

  dimension_grades: {
    determinism: results.determinism.grade,
    isolation: results.isolation.grade,
    maintainability: results.maintainability.grade,
    performance: results.performance.grade,
  },

  violations_summary: violationSummary,

  all_violations: allViolations,

  high_severity_violations: highSeverity,

  top_10_recommendations: prioritizedRecommendations,

  subagent_execution: 'PARALLEL (4 quality dimensions)',
  performance_gain: '~60% faster than sequential',
};

// Save for Step 4 (report generation)
fs.writeFileSync(`/tmp/tea-test-review-summary-${timestamp}.json`, JSON.stringify(reviewSummary, null, 2), 'utf8');

---

6. Display Summary to User

✅ Quality Evaluation Complete (Parallel Execution)

📊 Overall Quality Score: {roundedScore}/100 (Grade: {overallGrade})

📈 Dimension Scores:
- Determinism:      {determinism_score}/100 ({determinism_grade})
- Isolation:        {isolation_score}/100 ({isolation_grade})
- Maintainability:  {maintainability_score}/100 ({maintainability_grade})
- Performance:      {performance_score}/100 ({performance_grade})

ℹ️ Coverage is excluded from `test-review` scoring. Use `trace` for coverage analysis and gates.

⚠️ Violations Found:
- HIGH:   {high_count} violations
- MEDIUM: {medium_count} violations
- LOW:    {low_count} violations
- TOTAL:  {total_count} violations

🚀 Performance: Parallel execution ~60% faster than sequential

✅ Ready for report generation (Step 4)

---

---

7. Save Progress

Save this step's accumulated work to {outputFile}.

• If {outputFile} does not exist (first save), create it using the workflow template (if available) with YAML frontmatter:

  ---
  stepsCompleted: ['step-03f-aggregate-scores']
  lastStep: 'step-03f-aggregate-scores'
  lastSaved: '{date}'
  ---
  

  Then write this step's output below the frontmatter.

• If {outputFile} already exists, update:

  • Add 'step-03f-aggregate-scores' to stepsCompleted array (only if not already present)
  • Set lastStep: 'step-03f-aggregate-scores'
  • Set lastSaved: '{date}'
  • Append this step's output to the appropriate section of the document.

---

EXIT CONDITION

Proceed to Step 4 when:

• ✅ All subagent outputs read successfully
• ✅ Overall score calculated
• ✅ Violations aggregated
• ✅ Recommendations prioritized
• ✅ Summary saved to temp file
• ✅ Output displayed to user
• ✅ Progress saved to output document

Load next step: {nextStepFile}

---

🚨 SYSTEM SUCCESS METRICS

✅ SUCCESS:

• All 4 subagent outputs read and parsed
• Overall score calculated with proper weights
• Violations aggregated correctly
• Summary complete and saved

❌ FAILURE:

• Failed to read one or more subagent outputs
• Score calculation incorrect
• Summary missing or incomplete

Master Rule: Aggregate determinism, isolation, maintainability, and performance only.